Reviews
We would give it no stars if possible. It was our first and last time ordering from this place! Our order was delivered over an hour and a half after we placed the order, expecting 45 minutes. The pizza sat so long that the cheese slid all over the pie and you could barely tell it had even been cut. The wings were sitting in a pool of grease and the mozz sticks were gross (too little cheese and way too much batter). Either way, the best part of this meal was throwing it in the trash and making sandwiches. 
Dana — 8/13/2017
Very good
Trevor — 5/28/2017
EXCELLENT PIZZA AND SERVICE
Mary — 4/24/2017
Everything was great and on time
Richard — 1/27/2017
Everything was great and on time
Richard — 1/27/2017
Love their pizza
Mark — 1/16/2017
Placed my order at approx. 11:30 am, not being delivered until almost 1:30 p.m. Not a happy camper!
Karen — 12/22/2016
Love love love this pizza. Also the chocolate mousse is da bomb as well. This is one happy chick. :)
Mark — 12/8/2016
.
Mark — 12/8/2016
Our favorite pizza place
Mark — 11/3/2016
Absolutely love their pizza
Mark — 10/27/2016
Their food is very good and the delivery guy is nice. But this time they forgot my chicken tenders,. And once those were delivered, I see they forgot my side of sauce, as I was promised when I called. So I was disappointed.
Kelly — 8/17/2016
Was Delicious. I wish I ordered a larger one. My compliments to the cook. I wish there was consistency from order to order. Sometimes they are good and sometimes they are burned etc.
Richard — 7/25/2016
Everything was awesome, 10/10 will order again
Sierra — 6/23/2016
Pizza was burned underneath. Not tasty. Manager too busy to come to the phone. Offered another pizza, I declined. I should have received a full refund. Not ordering from there again.
Richard — 6/11/2016
edges of pizza crust very dark
Christine — 5/25/2016
Hot delicious food delivered timely
Christine — 4/29/2016
One of the freshest salads I've ever ordered from anywhere. Crispy with no wilted greens.
Christine — 4/8/2016
Pizza was delicious. Piece of cake was too small for the price. It should of been 2-3 times larger.
Richard — 12/20/2015
Order was convenient & simple to place. Ordered BBQ wings & got regular :/
David — 11/25/2015
It took quite a while for food to be delivered. I called to check on delivery estimate and was treated rudely by person on the phone. Fortunately when it did finally arrive, food was hot and tasted good.
Kathryn — 10/16/2015
We order food from here regularly and disappointed this time. We understand it's busy but our food was extremely greasy, cold, and soggy also our pizza was suppose to be half cheese and it wasn't.
Cass — 10/11/2015
took an hour and a half to get my pizza and it's cold
Thomas — 10/6/2015
Way too many onions and not enough other toppings
Richard — 9/4/2015
After an Hour of waiting for delivery, i called to inquiry as to where our pizza was and was told that it was "Out for delivery". A half an hour later, a car pulls into the driveway...
I open up the lukewarm pizza box and find a pizza with barely any cheese on it, which was especially annoying since i paid an extra $2 for extra cheese. I open up the box of wings and find a soggy mess.
An hour and a half of waiting, with a hungry family, only to get a less than acceptable meal... Very Disappointing
George — 7/31/2015
So the delivery guy shows up and begins to berate me at my door after he couldn't find the place for 20 minutes. I live on a main road, who delivers pizza and doesn't use a GPS? Food was cold obviously
Sarah — 7/19/2015
Always good food, always good to deal with. With all of the other places to eat around here, you always know what to expect here. Highly recommend!
Sonia — 5/26/2015
Pizza Was FANTASTIC Great Flavor Found My New Pizza Place When In The Albany Area . Thanks For Your Great Food
Alexander — 4/18/2015
I Love NY Food...all of it. Always exactly as I ordered it. I am not so fond of auto adding the tip to my online order though. I feel they under tip. I guess it's their loss I would have tipped higher!
Paula — 4/14/2015
Delicious as always
Jennifer — 4/8/2015
Absolutely disgusted with the way I was treated my the delivery man and the absolute CRAP they served to me because I placed an order at 11:30pm. As soon as I answered the door this rude deliver an shoves the food at me and says extremely rudely "you know you gotta place Ur orders earlier than this". The pizza and wings were thrown together soo badly that grease from the wing box AND bag had soaked through onto the pizza box it was sitting on top of. It was obvious they threw it together as fast as possible. I paid $30 for this crap and was treated terribly at the door. If you don't want to serve pizza until 12:30 at night then DONT ACCEPT ORDERS!, will never order from this crap restaurant again.
Rachel — 2/25/2015
very quick and convienent, thank u
Renee — 2/4/2015
Online ordering was simple but wrong pizza was delivered (2 PM). When I finally had a chance to call store at 7 PM (delay due to unexpected visitors showing up at our home), the woman at the store just apologized and said if we'd called earlier, they would have sent another pizza. She made it seem that it was more our fault for calling late than it was the store's fault for delivering the wrong pizza.
Thanh — 7/3/2014
These guys suck. 2.5 hours later and I still don't have my entire order. They're going to "figure out what happened". WTF is that. It's take out, not rocket science. Order here if you feel like rolling the dice.
Adam — 1/3/2014
Horrible place. Customer service is disgusting and good was gross.
Linda — 1/2/2014
Awesome. Very quick delivery, food is delicious.
Trevor — 10/6/2013
Great, quick delivery and food is very good.
Trevor — 10/6/2013
Prompt service and one of the best pizza's I've had in a long time. The buffalo chicken pizza is excellent!
Jason — 9/23/2013
Great, took exactly 45 minutes. It was delicious.
Mary — 9/9/2013
dekicious pizza great customer service will do it agani next time i am in town
laurie — 8/24/2013
Chicken Marsala pizza is delicious!!
Shane — 6/14/2013
Order was hot, fresh and delicious. Super fast delivery was very much appreciated on a busy afternoon at the office. Thanks guys!!
Jennifer — 5/27/2013
Very good wings and pizza!
Ricardo — 4/2/2013
Amazing service& friendly staff! Always serving customers with a smile. The pizza's are delicious& the eggplant parmigiana /white broccoli ricotta are to die for. Your truly missing out if you don't give it a try!
Kayla — 1/8/2013
Perfect
DAVID — 12/21/2012
Great as always! Went for motz sticks instead of wings for a change here at the office... huge and perfectly cooked!
DAVID — 12/21/2012
This place is a guarantee. Anything they make, they make well so order anything!
DAVID — 11/12/2012
bomb ass pizza
John — 10/26/2012
Our Favorite Pizza Place!!!!
Jeanna — 12/21/2010
easy ordering
jason — 11/6/2010
easy ordering
jason — 11/6/2010
easy ordering
jason — 11/6/2010
Took an hour to arrive. Other than that, it was good.
sam — 8/12/2010
Before you read on about us, we want to let you know that you are looking at the I LOVE NY PIZZA located in Colonie across Kohls plaza and Colonie Beverage.
We at I Love NY Pizza appreciate your business and would like to thank you for your support. We only use Grande cheese and we make our dough fresh every day. For our sauce, we only use fresh, whole plum tomatoes and the best vegetables and spices available. We work hard to meet your needs. From our family to yours....
Voted #1 Thirteen (Yes, 13) years in a row...ORDER ONLINE now and we'll deliver right to your door. Order for pick-up and it will be ready when you arrive!
