Back to restaurant list

Italiano's New York Pizza 3 out of 5 stars

  • 1338 Gerling St
    Schenectady, NY 12308
  • Order Minimum: $15.00
  • Delivery Time: 35-50 minutes
  • Prep Time: 10-25 minutes
Restaurant Description

Italiano's New York Pizza is back under it's old ownership! Located in Schenectady, NY this place is a treat for the locals. Italian Style Pizza, with the freshest ingredients. You can be sure of ordering again and again after trying this Authentic Italian Pizza! We serve it all - choose from Italian Dinners, Subs, Wings, Salads, Appetizers, and Desserts. Italiano's Pizza is better than ever, and bringing delicious pizza to Schenectady, NY. Order online now and rekindle your hungry relationship with Italiano's!

Italiano's New York Pizza offers American, Cakes, Catering, Greek, Italian, Mexican, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Seafood, Steak, Subs, Wings, Wraps.

ORDER ONLINE right here on Mealeo and we'll deliver it right to your door!

Delivery Hours
  • Mon 4:00pm - 8:30pm
  • Tues 4:00pm - 8:30pm
  • Wed 4:00pm - 8:30pm
  • Thurs 4:00pm - 8:30pm
  • Fri 11:00am - 9:30pm
  • Sat 11:00am - 9:30pm
  • Sun 11:00am - 8:30pm
Restaurant Photos

The food was good, but it took over an hour to get it. They didn't have most of the toppings and said they'd give me a refund for my inconvenience. Almost 2 weeks and a half dozen phone calls later with no answer and no refund. I went over to the restaurant and it's closed during normal business hours.

Ryan — 22 days ago 1 out of 5 stars

Do not order from this restaurant. Today I ordered dinner for me an my roommate consisting of two slices of pizza, a buffalo chicken sub., onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and two sodas. The estimated wait for delivery time was 35-50 minutes. The food took close to two hours to be delivered and when it was without even mentioning the long wait time the delivery guy was rude and making a lot of excuses. He assured me that all my items were there and left in a hurry. The onion rings and soda were missing, there were french fries included that I didn't order, the pizza was bland and inedible, and the sub was burnt to a crisp. I have never in my life asked for a refund but given that this order cost 40$ including tip, was over an hour late, and didn't resemble anything as advertised I felt I had no choice. I called and was given a ton of excuses again and that I couldn't receive a refund but that they would remake the food and bring it over immediately. That was three hours ago so I have now spent 40$ to wait 5 hours with no edible food or call to explain the delay. I should have read other reviews here before I ordered because they indicate that long delivery times and poor service are a trend as this restaurant and not a fluke as the manager's excuses wanted me to believe. ORDER AT YOUR OWN RISK!!

Kevin — 4/3/2017 1 out of 5 stars

Tonight, I ordered from this place for the 1st time in months, to give them another chance after a period of episodes where delivery was over an hour (I live less than 1/2 mile... I order from work & have it delivered so my kids can eat ahead, if I need to work late). The timestamp of tonight's order is 6:59 pm. I had to call at 8:17 pm to have them cancel the order for kids chicken fingers, boneless wings and garlic knots which had not yet arrived, even after 1 hr, 20 minutes.

Antoinette — 3/16/2017 1 out of 5 stars

The food was pretty good, but it took them 2 hours to get it to me. By the time it finally showed up, it was cold. I had to call twice and was told both times it would arrive any minute. I will not order from this place again.

Ken — 8/28/2016 1 out of 5 stars

I don't like leaving negative reviews and I'm generally very patient when waiting for delivery food. However, it took over two hours for a single pizza and we heard three different reasons for the delay from three different employees. When we finally got our food, the pizza dough was undercooked and still raw in some parts of the crust. We will not be ordering again.

Jill — 8/15/2016 1 out of 5 stars

You showed up before the delivery time. Now that's fast! Excellent food! Thank you!

Susan — 6/18/2016 5 out of 5 stars

Thank you for the excellent food and super fast delivery! I really appreciate your phone call to ensure that I had what I needed. And the triple chocolate cake ... heaven! Thanks for taking care of me. As always! :)

Susan — 6/18/2016 5 out of 5 stars

amazing as always

Caroline — 2/21/2016 5 out of 5 stars


Caroline — 1/10/2016 5 out of 5 stars

You must be logged into your account to save favorites.

Fill out the fields below to create a free account now.

Your Order:

Italiano's New York Pizza is not accepting online orders at this time.